On May 18, 2026, the Smith County Sheriff’s Office Patrol Division received a report regarding the theft of two dogs. A witness informed responding deputies that they observed a delivery driver pick up the animals. When contacted, the driver’s supervisor instructed the driver to return the dogs; however, the animals were never brought back.
The case was assigned to the Criminal Investigation Division (CID) for followup. Through the investigation, the driver was identified as 57-year-old Susan Garrett. Investigators responded to her residence, where they recovered the two stolen dogs from a family member since Mrs. Garrett was not home. While at the location, investigators noted a strong odor of feces and urine coming from both inside the home and the backyard. When the dogs were returned to their owner, they were found to be covered in fleas, matted with feces, and showing signs of weight loss.
The following day, investigators returned to the residence to speak with Ms. Garrett. They again encountered the same strong odor and heard numerous dogs barking inside the home. Due to the condition of the recovered dogs and the likelihood of additional animals being in similar circumstances, Smith County Animal Control was contacted to assist.
Ms. Garrett granted consent for investigators and Animal Control personnel to enter the residence. Upon entry, they discovered extremely unsanitary living conditions for both animals and humans. A total of 38 dogs were located inside and outside the residence. Investigators observed layers of dried and fresh feces throughout the home, as well as a non-functioning air conditioner, resulting in stagnant and unhealthy air quality. All of the dogs appeared dirty and exhibited signs of skin issues.
Investigators subsequently obtained two arrest warrants for Ms. Garrett, issued by the Honorable Judge Jackson of the 114th District Court. The charges include:
• Theft of Property, $50–$500, with a bond set at $5,000
• Cruelty to NonLivestock Animals, with a bond set at $10,000
It is believed that Mrs. Garrett has left town and her whereabouts are unknown, she is currently wanted on these charges, so if you have any information, please contact the Smith County Sheriff’s Office at 903-566-6600.
Smith County Animal Control is currently seeking foster homes for several of the dogs removed from the residence. Individuals interested in fostering may contact them at (903) 266-4303.